Spiegelhoff Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin partnering with AM Best A-rated insurance companies. We do the shopping for you saving you time and money. We specialize in personal auto, homeowner's, renter's insurance, condo insurance, life insurance, health insurance and commercial insurance for businesses of all sizes.

Spiegelhoff Insurance was founded in 1981 by Joe Spiegelhoff to provide insurance solutions for southeastern Wisconsin. Today, Spiegelhoff Insurance is still family owned and operated, licensed in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa.

Personalized Service

We provide our clients with personalized insurance solutions

Expert Advice

Our focus is on educating our clients about their insurance choices so that they can make well-informed decisions.


As an independent agent, we can find the right insurance fit from many different companies, instead of just one.


We work with top rated companies to provide the best value on the following types of insurance:

Personal Lines

- Automobile Insurance
- Homeowner's Insurance
- Renter's Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Motorcycle Insurance
- RV/Boat Insurance

Commercial Lines

- General Liability Insurance
- Property Insurance
- Rental Properties Insurance
- Commercial Automobile Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Bonds

Life and Health

- Group Health Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Short Term Health Insurance

What our customers have to say

We'd love to hear from you too!


Click on the person you'd like to speak with to send an e-mail directly to them.

Josh Spiegelhoff


Luke Spiegelhoff


Vice President


Good Boy

Chris Zegarra

Habla Espanol

Ryan Lasch


Jeremy Nafziger

J. Nafziger


Carrie Fecteau

Client Relations Manager

Facebook Feed

'Like' Us to get Our updates right in your News Feed
This serves as a great reminder to insure what matters most—with life insurance. Disclaimer: Erie Family Life Insurance Company (Erie, PA). ERIE® life insurance products are not available in New York. Go to erieinsurance.com for company licensure and product details. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
We are sad to announce Joseph Spiegelhoff passed away Friday, August 25, 2023 at his home in Lake Geneva surrounded by his loving family. Joe founded Spiegelhoff Insurance in 1981 out of the basement of his house on Wheeler Street in Lake Geneva. He had a staff of 6 working there while having a young family trying their best to stay quiet upstairs. He started as a scratch agent focusing on life insurance in the early days before transitioning into property and casualty insurance. Joe was proud to pass the business to his two boys, Joshua and Luke Spiegelhoff who took over the agency in 2014. During retirement Joe spent time between Fort Myers, Florida and Lake Geneva. He was proud that the business stayed in the family and only wished he and the two boys would have worked longer together.Joe lived a fulfilling life in Lake Geneva serving the community. He was a long time insurance agent, served on the school board for Joint 1 in Lake Geneva and gave back to numerous organizations and charities. We have included a few pictures. There is an article from the Regional News when the business transitioned out of the basement of the Wheeler Street house to Geneva Square before moving to the current location on Wells Street. There is a picture of him and his boys enjoying life and one of him in his much loved Model A. Services will be held late next week. Please feel free to drop a message or a memory of Joe. He will be greatly missed. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
We all know life happens. That’s why you’ll want to schedule a life insurance review after a major life event. Disclaimer: Erie life insurance and annuity products and services are provided by Erie Family Life Insurance Company (home office: Erie, Pennsylvania.) Erie Family Life Insurance Company is not licensed to operate in all states. ERIE life insurance products are not available in New York. Go to erieinsurance.com for company licensure and product information. ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook