Spiegelhoff Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin partnering with AM Best A-rated insurance companies. We do the shopping for you saving you time and money. We specialize in personal auto, homeowner's, renter's insurance, condo insurance, life insurance, health insurance and commercial insurance for businesses of all sizes.

Spiegelhoff Insurance was founded in 1981 by Joe Spiegelhoff to provide insurance solutions for southeastern Wisconsin. Today, Spiegelhoff Insurance is still family owned and operated, licensed in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa.

Personalized Service

We provide our clients with personalized insurance solutions

Expert Advice

Our focus is on educating our clients about their insurance choices so that they can make well-informed decisions.


As an independent agent, we can find the right insurance fit from many different companies, instead of just one.


We work with top rated companies to provide the best value on the following types of insurance:

Personal Lines

- Automobile Insurance
- Homeowner's Insurance
- Renter's Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Motorcycle Insurance
- RV/Boat Insurance

Commercial Lines

- General Liability Insurance
- Property Insurance
- Rental Properties Insurance
- Commercial Automobile Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Bonds

Life and Health

- Group Health Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Short Term Health Insurance

What our customers have to say

We'd love to hear from you too!


Click on the person you'd like to speak with to send an e-mail directly to them.

Josh Spiegelhoff



Luke Spiegelhoff


Vice President

Kelly Pankonin



Chris Zegarra


Habla Espanol

Ryan Lasch

Facebook Just Logo


Jeremy Nafziger

jeremy headshot


Facebook Feed

'Like' Us to get Our updates right in your News Feed
5 days ago

As a reminder when dropping off check payments at the office, the checks need to be made out to "Spiegelhoff Insurance." Please contact us at (262) 248-9502 with any questions. You can also find ... See more

3 weeks ago

Happy New Year! Here is to a safe and fun night ahead. We will be open Saturday from 9 am - 12 pm and Monday from 8 am - 12 pm and closed on New Year's Day. Enjoy the festivities! See you next ... See more

1 month ago
IIHS: The Safest Cars of 2019

Car shopping? It's the most wonderful time of the year! Find a link to this year's (2019) IIHS safest cars of ... See more

The results are in: See which makes and models earned the TOP SAFETY PICK awards from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

1 month ago

We have different hours for the upcoming Christmas holiday. We will be open this Saturday, December 22nd from 9 AM - 12 PM and also on Christmas Eve from 8 AM - 12 PM. We will be closed on December ... See more

1 month ago
SECURA Insurance - Holiday home safety tips

House fires are more frequent during this time of the year. Due to gatherings there are more kitchen fires because of the amount of cooking coupled with distractions. Candles are one of the leading ... See more

With a little preparation and mindfulness, you can help avoid a holiday disaster.

1 month ago

Wrote a 20 year $90,000 term for a 32 year old male for $16/month with no medical exam. Life insurance should be part of your family planning and won't break the bank. Give us a call at ... See more

1 month ago
10 Tips to Host a Holiday Party (Without Stressing Out)

Hosting a holiday get together? Is your house hosting Christmas? A quick list of the top 10 things to help you keep your hosting duties as stress free as ... See more

Reduce stress and wow your guests this holiday season with these expert-backed tips.

1 month ago

We are providing our clients with a lot of life insurance quotes and are finding some clients are intimidated by the medical portion of underwriting. We offer several life insurance products that ... See more

1 month ago

There is a lot of rain forecasted for our area on Saturday and Sunday. Rain with a healthy amount of snow already on the ground is not a great combination. Make sure you and your home are prepared. ... See more

1 month ago
Home Insurance Support

Erie is offering, for a limited time, a free home sensor product that will measure temperature and humidity in your home alerting you via smart phone to any problems like a water leak or potential ... See more

Find answers to your home insurance questions in Erie Insurance’s Support Center.

« 1 of 4 »