Spiegelhoff Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin partnering with AM Best A-rated insurance companies. We do the shopping for you saving you time and money. We specialize in personal auto, homeowner's, renter's insurance, condo insurance, life insurance, health insurance and commercial insurance for businesses of all sizes.

Spiegelhoff Insurance was founded in 1981 by Joe Spiegelhoff to provide insurance solutions for southeastern Wisconsin. Today, Spiegelhoff Insurance is still family owned and operated, licensed in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa.

Personalized Service

We provide our clients with personalized insurance solutions

Expert Advice

Our focus is on educating our clients about their insurance choices so that they can make well-informed decisions.


As an independent agent, we can find the right insurance fit from many different companies, instead of just one.


We work with top rated companies to provide the best value on the following types of insurance:

Personal Lines

- Automobile Insurance
- Homeowner's Insurance
- Renter's Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Motorcycle Insurance
- RV/Boat Insurance

Commercial Lines

- General Liability Insurance
- Property Insurance
- Rental Properties Insurance
- Commercial Automobile Insurance
- Umbrella Insurance
- Bonds

Life and Health

- Group Health Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Short Term Health Insurance

What our customers have to say

We'd love to hear from you too!


Click on the person you'd like to speak with to send an e-mail directly to them.

Josh Spiegelhoff



Luke Spiegelhoff


Vice President

Kelly Pankonin



Chris Zegarra


Habla Espanol

Ryan Lasch

Facebook Just Logo


Jeremy Nafziger

jeremy headshot


Facebook Feed

'Like' Us to get Our updates right in your News Feed
2 months ago

Today is the first day of open enrollment for health insurance with a start date of 01/01/2019. As a reminder, we have made the difficult decision to no longer sell ACA plans in the office.

We will ... See more

2 months ago

Happy Halloween from your friends at Spiegelhoff Insurance!! #brawnyman #maleficent #fisherman

2 months ago
Fact or Fiction? Debunking Deer Collisions

Deer myths! Do deer whistles work? Nope! There has never been a study to prove that affixing deer whistles to your bumper will scare deer away from your vehicle.

If you hit a deer can you take ... See more

Will a whistle actually scare deer away from your car? Learn which deer rumors are fact, and which are fiction.

2 months ago
5 Common Problems Caused by Clogged Gutters

Water - a homeowner's biggest problem. Keeping your gutters clean and in good repair is a great step in keeping water out of your home. And it's that time of year to get the leaves and whatever ... See more

What can actually happen if you don't clean your gutters? Let's find out.

3 months ago

Health Insurance! Everyone's favorite topic. The rates for 2019 do not come out until open enrollment opens on November 1st and runs through December 15th. This is the only time you can open ... See more

3 months ago
What to Do When You Hit a Deer

October and November are the two most common months to hit a deer while driving. What should you do if you have an unexpected collision with a ... See more

Have you had a collision and need help? Here's what to do when you hit a deer on the road: 5 steps to handling the situation

3 months ago
Why you'll be using a fingerprint to start your car soon

Will your car insurance get cheaper if you own a car that requires your finger print to start the car? That appears to be the reality in the next 2-4 ... See more

4 months ago

We write a ton of general liability and Business Owner Policies for contractors. Trades like carpentry, roofing, residential building, drywall, plumbing, HVAC, electrical, framing and flooring. ... See more

4 months ago

Today we remember the attacks of 9/11 and are proud of the men and women that serve and sacrifice here and abroad along with their police, fire and other first responder brethren. #neverforget

4 months ago
Purple Protection Posse's Walk to End Alzheimer's Team Page

Our business is very much involved in the local community and because of this we will be closed this Saturday to take part in the Walk to End Alzheimer's taking place in Library Park Saturday ... See more

Purple Protection Posse has joined the fight to end Alzheimer's. Donate today and help us reach our goal.

« 3 of 4 »